It's time to drag detector design out of the drak ages

May 26, 2023
by Ivan Raconteur

I have detected a serious flaw in the design of smoke detectors.

Now, before I attract the ire of firefighters and other smoke detector advocates, I want to make it perfectly clear that I understand the value of these devices, and I believe that when properly maintained, they can save lives.

My grievance concerns the design of the devices. It is 2023, and they don’t seem to have evolved for decades.

I was reminded of this recently when I heard the familiar high-pitched chirp indicating a battery needed to be replaced. I generally replace all of them at once when we change the clocks, but they seem to wear out at different rates.

The first step is to figure out which detector needs attention. This isn’t as simple as it sounds because there are so many of them scattered all throughout the house, often in inconvenient places. If you have been roused from a sound sleep, the task becomes even more arduous.

Then there is the task of actually changing the battery. I grab a fresh battery from the designated slot in the linen closet and prepare to do battle.

First, I have to get close enough to reach the device. I’m not able to climb ladders anymore, but I remember what it was like when I could.

There is an urgency caused by wanting to make the brain-numbing shrieks stop. One has to figure out how to disengage the device from the ceiling, no small task when it is chirping in your face. The connectors tend to be stiff, with an absurd design.

Once one disengages the unit from the ceiling, replacing the battery is relatively easy.

Re-attaching the wire assembly and attaching the device to the ceiling is not so simple. Because they are hard-wired with a battery backup, one only has a few inches of wire to work with. This makes it difficult to match up the bizarre plug with the receiver.

This is more difficult if one has limited vision and, of course, when one is completing the operation while balancing at the top of a stepladder.

It seems there are many ways this important task could be made easier and more pleasant.

I understand why the alarm is so obnoxious. It is intended to alert people at all hours and send them scurrying to safety. However, there’s no reason the battery replacement alert needs to be that urgent. A quieter, gentler reminder tone would be sufficient.

Technology makes LED lights inexpensive, which is why they are installed on nearly all of the devices in our homes. It would be helpful if there was a light to tell us which battery needed to be replaced, so it would not be necessary to run all over the house listening.

Finally, the actual method of replacing the battery could be much simpler. It shouldn’t even be necessary to disengage the detector from the ceiling. An easy-to-open access panel on the exterior of the device would make the process infinitely easier.

These simple steps to modernize smoke detector design could improve the quality of life for all of us.

Advertise in over
250+ MN newspapers